Ghosty_ToastyXD: Messmer and midra definately had the smoothest moveset in the dlc
Dark_kage: Romina is definitely better than Gaius
Avienity: How to make Radahn SSS Tier:
1.) Reduce Lightshow
2.) Remove Cross Slash
Silver_Lloyd: Okay disregarding everything else I find the implications of putting Radahn next to a "Demihuman" on a tier list very funny.
panzerj5356: Ymir teleported outside the map and killed himself before I could even hit him lol
dannattack4211: Gaius E tier. Minimal coolness. Worst hitboxes. Boring fight. Long fight.
Ramdas_Devadiga: Messmer/Rellana are the "Dance with me" bosses. Bayle and Midra are the "Look at me dance" bosses.

I wholeheartedly agree with the list apart from Radhan. I'd rate this boss as B -tier. You just feel glad its over unlike the S tier bosses which makes you want to replay the game just to face off with them.
thebluehood35: Here’s how I’d tackle the list:
God-Tier: Messmer
S: Midra, Bayle, Promised Consort, Rellana
A: Romina, Death Knights (One of my favourite minibosses aside Crucible Knights), Divine Beast
B: Putrescent Knight, Demi-Human Swordmaster Onze, Scadutree Avatar, Red Bears, Gaius
C: the NPC fights, Metyr, Ghostflame Dragon
D: Golden Hippo, Furnace Golem
E: Jori

(Extra Note: I don’t include the bosses that were already in the base game unless they have features unique enough, like the Ghostflame Dragon)
malikhittam1440: Death knights being any lower than A tier is a crime. If this was ds3 those guys would be an actual main story boss
jasonheath7045: Out of all dlc bosses I'd give Commander Gaius the lowest rank, at least they fixed the Golden Hippopotamus' hitboxes but they didn't fix Gaius' horrible hitboxes

Messmer, Midra, Rellana, Bayle, and Romina are definitely in the top of the list for me

(Midra is my Rune arc farm when being summoned to help players lol, I've helped over 150 players so far)
Malfeasance1: Fights that feel like elaborate dances, rather than a struggle to even breathe, are always my favorite and that's why Messmer is the easy standout for me with Midra being close second. To me they felt like they were quintessential hard-but-fair "Souls" fights and remain the most memorable (besides Igon and Bayle's incredible spectacle).
riffieboi3437: The one thing I remember about the rakshasa fight was how she decided to use her AoW and never stopped
chris_wizzudz: Gaius is way
multifleks: Saying that Romina is mid because she's annoying and then putting Scadutree/Gaius above her is pretty wild

Sep 04 2024

Buy Elden Ring Runes